Tavern Cellar

The Walking Dead: The Big Scary U – Negan’s Secrets, Gabriel’s Guilt, and a Savior Showdown (Season 8, Episode 5)

Originally aired: November 19, 2017. 7.85 million viewers tuned in for this character-driven episode. Written by Scott M. Gimple, David Leslie Johnson-McGoldrick, and Angela Kang, and directed by Michael E. Satrazemis.

The Sanctuary: Where the Walls are Closing In:

“The Big Scary U” shifts the focus back to the Sanctuary, where Negan and his Saviors are feeling the pressure of the siege. Tensions are rising within their ranks, and the once-unquestioned authority of Negan is starting to crumble.

Key Plot Points (With My Signature Sass):

• Negan and Gabriel: The Odd Couple (of the Apocalypse): Negan and Gabriel, who found themselves trapped together in a trailer at the end of the last episode, are still trying to figure out how to survive the walker horde outside.¹ But their predicament also leads to some surprisingly deep conversations. Gabriel, bless his inquisitive heart, tries to understand Negan’s motivations and his twisted worldview. Negan, in a rare moment of vulnerability, shares glimpses of his past and the events that shaped him into the ruthless leader he is today. Negan and Gabriel: the therapy session we didn’t know we needed.
• Negan’s Backstory: The Man Behind the Bat: Negan reveals that he was once a gym teacher (who knew?) and that he lost his wife to cancer in the early days of the apocalypse. He admits that he made mistakes in the past, and he’s haunted by guilt and regret. But he also justifies his brutal methods as necessary to maintain order and protect his people. Negan: the villain who’s trying to convince himself (and Gabriel) that he’s the good guy.
• Gabriel’s Confession: The Priest Who Lost His Flock: Gabriel, in a moment of shared vulnerability, confesses his own sin. He admits that he locked his congregation out of his church at the beginning of the apocalypse, leaving them to die at the hands of the walkers.² His confession creates an unexpected connection with Negan, who seems to respect Gabriel’s honesty and his willingness to take responsibility for his actions. Gabriel: the priest who’s finding redemption in the most unlikely of places.
• Savior Showdown: The Power Struggle: With Negan trapped outside the Sanctuary, the Saviors’ leadership is in disarray. Simon, Dwight, and the other lieutenants are vying for power, and their conflicting opinions and strategies create tension and chaos within the ranks. Dwight, secretly working with Rick’s group, uses the opportunity to sow discord and undermine the Saviors’ morale. The Saviors: they’re like a pack of wolves without an alpha.
• Negan’s Return: The King is Back!: Negan, with Gabriel’s help, manages to escape the trailer and return to the Sanctuary. He quickly reasserts his authority, quelling the dissent among his followers and reminding them who’s in charge. Negan: the man who always knows how to make an entrance (and crush a rebellion).!
• Rick and Daryl: The Bromance is Broken?: Rick and Daryl, who have always been the best of friends and the core of the group’s leadership, clash over their tactics in the war against the Saviors. Daryl, fueled by anger and grief, wants to use the explosives they’ve found to blow up the Sanctuary, even if it means risking civilian casualties. Rick, however, is more cautious and concerned about the moral implications of such a move. Their disagreement highlights the growing divide within the group and the challenges of maintaining unity in the face of war. Rick and Daryl: the brothers who are starting to see the world differently.

Themes and Meanings (With My Insightful Commentary):

• Leadership: The Many Faces of Power: “The Big Scary U” explores the different facets of leadership in the apocalypse. Negan’s authoritarian approach, Rick’s moral dilemmas, and Daryl’s pragmatism all represent different ways of leading and making decisions in a world gone mad. Leadership: it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution.
• Guilt and Redemption: The Weight of the Past: Negan and Gabriel’s confessions about their past actions highlight the theme of guilt and the search for redemption. They’ve both made mistakes, they’ve both hurt people, and they’re both trying to find a way to come to terms with their pasts. The apocalypse: it’s a world where even the worst of us can seek forgiveness.
• Loyalty: The Ties That Bind (and Break): The internal struggles within the Saviors’ ranks show the fragility of loyalty in the apocalypse. When the leader’s power is challenged, the followers start to question their allegiances and look out for themselves. Dwight’s secret betrayal of Negan is a sign that the Saviors’ unity is cracking, and it could be the key to their downfall. Loyalty: it’s a precious commodity in the apocalypse, but it’s also easily broken.

Little Details You Might Have Missed (Because I’m a Detail Detective):

• Negan’s mention of his wife, Lucille, and the origin of his bat’s name adds a layer of complexity to his character. It shows that even the most ruthless villains have a human side, and that their actions are often driven by love and loss. Negan: the man who’s still grieving his wife (and maybe taking it out on the world).!
• Gabriel’s illness after covering himself in walker guts is a reminder of the constant dangers of the apocalypse, even for those who are trying to do good. Gabriel: the priest who’s always getting into trouble.
• Dwight’s subtle acts of sabotage against the Saviors, like leaving the gate open for the walkers, show his growing commitment to helping Rick’s group and his desire to see Negan overthrown. Dwight: the double agent who’s playing a dangerous game.

Stats and Stuff (Numbers Don’t Lie):

• Walker Kills: 10+ (Negan and Gabriel make a surprisingly good team).
• Human Deaths: None (but the tension is thicker than walker guts).
• Survivor Count: Stable, but the Saviors’ grip on power is weakening.

My Final Verdict (With Extra Pizzazz):

“The Big Scary U” is a fascinating and complex episode that delves into the inner workings of the Saviors and the moral dilemmas of survival in the apocalypse. Negan’s backstory, Gabriel’s confession, and the power struggles within the Sanctuary all contribute to the intrigue and suspense of the episode. This is “The Walking Dead” at its most thought-provoking, reminding us that even the most ruthless villains have their own vulnerabilities, and that the fight for freedom is not just about physical strength, but also about mental and emotional resilience. What did you think of the episode? Were you surprised by Negan’s backstory? Let’s discuss in the comments! And don’t forget to subscribe for more “Walking Dead” recaps with extra sass!