Tavern Cellar

The Walking Dead: The Same Boat – Carol’s Crisis, Maggie’s Strength, and a Savior Showdown (Season 6, Episode 13)

Originally aired: March 13, 2016. 12.53 million viewers tuned in for this intense and emotional episode. Written by Angela Kang and directed by Billy Gierhart.

Captivity and Confrontation:

“The Same Boat” picks up where “Not Tomorrow Yet” left off, with Carol and Maggie captured by a group of Saviors.² But these ladies are not your average damsels in distress. They’re resourceful, they’re resilient, and they’re not afraid to get their hands dirty (or bloody) to survive.

Key Plot Points:

• Bound and Determined: Carol and Maggie’s Captivity: Carol and Maggie find themselves tied up and at the mercy of Paula and her crew of Saviors.³ Paula, who’s a hardened and pragmatic survivor, sees a lot of herself in Carol, and their interactions are filled with tension and unspoken understanding. Carol, however, is playing a dangerous game. She’s pretending to be weak and scared, but we all know she’s just biding her time, waiting for the right moment to strike. Carol Peletier: the woman who can fool you with a smile (and then stab you in the back).!
• Paula’s Past: A Mirror Image?: We get some flashbacks that reveal Paula’s backstory. She was once an ordinary woman, a secretary who was just trying to survive in the apocalypse. But the world changed her, forcing her to make tough choices and do things she never thought she was capable of. Her story mirrors Carol’s own journey, highlighting the ways in which the apocalypse can transform people. Paula: the Savior who could have been Carol.
• Carol’s Crisis of Faith (in Humanity): Carol’s inner turmoil is on full display in this episode. She’s struggling with the weight of her past actions, the people she’s killed, and the person she’s become. Her apparent fear and hesitation are partly a tactic to deceive her captors, but they also reflect her genuine struggle with the moral implications of her choices. Carol Peletier: the woman who’s trying to find her way back from the darkness.
• Maggie’s Mama Bear Mode: Protecting Her Cub: Maggie, despite being pregnant and facing a dangerous situation, shows incredible strength and resolve. She refuses to back down or show weakness, and her determination to protect her unborn child fuels her fight for survival. Maggie Greene: the mama bear who’s not afraid to claw her way out of any cage.
• The Great Escape: Girl Power!: Carol and Maggie, using their combined wit and ruthlessness, manage to turn the tables on their captors.⁴ They break free, they fight back, and they kill all of the Saviors in a bloody and intense showdown. It’s a thrilling escape, but it also leaves them both shaken and questioning the cost of their actions. Carol and Maggie: the badass duo who just proved that you don’t mess with mama bears (or pregnant women).!
• The Aftermath: Scars and Doubts: Rick and the group arrive to rescue Carol and Maggie, but the experience has left its mark on them. Carol’s demeanor is somber, and she’s clearly struggling with the darkness that’s growing inside her. Maggie also expresses her doubts and fears, wondering if they’re losing their humanity in the fight for survival. The survivors: they’re alive, but they’re also carrying the weight of their choices.

Themes and Meanings:

• Survival vs. Morality: The Tightrope Walk: “The Same Boat” explores the delicate balance between survival and morality in the apocalypse. Carol and Maggie’s actions, while necessary for their survival, also raise questions about the cost of violence and the lengths people are willing to go to protect themselves and their loved ones. The apocalypse: it’s a world where the lines between right and wrong are often blurred.
• Identity: The Changing Face of Survival: Carol’s internal conflict reflects the way in which the apocalypse can change a person’s identity. She’s not the same woman she was before the world fell apart, and she’s struggling to reconcile her past self with the hardened survivor she’s become. The Walking Dead: where survival can mean losing yourself (or finding a new version of yourself).!
• Strength: The Power Within: Maggie’s resilience and determination in the face of danger showcase the strength of the human spirit. She’s a fighter, a protector, and a leader, and she’s not going to let anything stand in her way, not even a group of murderous Saviors. Maggie Greene: the woman who’s not afraid to face her fears (and kick some butt along the way).!

Little Details You Might Have Missed:

• Carol using a cigarette as a weapon is a clever and unexpected move. It shows her resourcefulness and her ability to think outside the box (or the cigarette pack). Carol Peletier: the woman who can turn anything into a weapon (even a nicotine fix).!
• The parallels between Paula’s backstory and Carol’s journey emphasize the potential paths one can take in the apocalypse. It’s a reminder that even the most hardened survivors were once ordinary people who were forced to adapt to a brutal new world. The apocalypse: it can change anyone, for better or for worse.
• Maggie’s hesitation to kill the Saviors, even when her life is on the line, shows her internal conflict about the morality of violence. She’s not a natural killer, and she’s still trying to hold onto her values, even in the midst of chaos. Maggie Greene: the woman who’s trying to find a balance between survival and humanity.

Stats and Stuff:

• Savior Kills: 6 (Carol and Maggie are cleaning up the apocalypse, one Savior at a time).
• Human Deaths: Multiple (the Saviors learn that you don’t mess with these ladies).
• Survivor Count: Stable, but the emotional scars run deep.

My Final Verdict:

“The Same Boat” is a powerful and thought-provoking episode that explores the dark side of survival and the complexities of human nature in the apocalypse. Carol and Maggie’s harrowing experience as captives and their eventual escape showcase their strength, resilience, and the enduring bonds of friendship. This episode is a reminder that even in the most brutal of circumstances, there’s still room for compassion, empathy, and the hope for a better tomorrow. What did you think of the episode? Were you shocked by Carol’s actions? Let’s discuss in the comments!