Tavern Cellar

The Walking Dead: The Calm Before – The Fair, the Whisperers, and the Pikes of Doom (Season 9, Episode 15)

Originally aired: March 24, 2019. 4.15 million viewers tuned in for this pivotal episode. Written by Scott M. Gimple and directed by Greg Nicotero.

The Kingdom: A Celebration of Hope (and a Prelude to Horror):

“The Calm Before” starts with a joyous occasion – the long-awaited fair at the Kingdom. The communities have come together to celebrate their unity, their resilience, and their hope for a brighter future. But as we all know, in the world of “The Walking Dead,” happiness is often fleeting, and darkness is always lurking around the corner.

Key Plot Points:

• The Fair: Fun, Games, and Foreshadowing: The Kingdom is alive with excitement as the fair gets underway. The survivors are trading goods, sharing stories, and enjoying a rare moment of peace and community. But amidst the laughter and the festivities, there’s an undercurrent of tension. The Whisperers are still out there, and their presence is a constant reminder that the world is not as safe as it seems. The fair: a celebration of life (and a reminder that death is always close behind).!
• The Charter: Signing on the Dotted Line (of Trust): Ezekiel and Carol, the king and queen of optimism, oversee the signing of a charter that formalizes the alliance between the communities. It’s a symbolic moment, representing their commitment to unity and their hope for a better future. But the charter is also a fragile document, and the events that follow will put its strength to the test. The charter: a piece of paper that’s about to be stained with blood.
• Alpha’s Sneaky Sneak: The Whisperer in Disguise: Alpha, the creepy and cunning leader of the Whisperers, infiltrates the fair. She’s disguised as one of the fairgoers, blending in with the crowd and observing the survivors’ every move. Her presence is a chilling reminder that the enemy is closer than they think, and that even in the midst of celebration, danger can lurk around every corner. Alpha: the master of disguise (and the queen of creepy).!
• The Search Party: Daryl, Michonne, and the Case of the Missing Teenager: Henry, the lovestruck teenager who followed Lydia into Whisperer territory, has gone missing (again). Daryl, Michonne, Carol, and Yumiko set out to find him, but they stumble upon something far more sinister – Alpha and a group of Whisperers. Alpha delivers a chilling ultimatum, warning the survivors to stay out of their territory or face the consequences. The Whisperers: they’re not just creepy; they’re also territorial.
• The Pikes of Doom: “Heads Will Roll” (Literally): The episode’s most shocking and devastating moment comes when the survivors discover a gruesome sight – ten decapitated heads mounted on pikes, marking the boundary of Whisperer territory. Among the victims are Tara, Enid, and Henry, whose deaths leave the communities reeling and heartbroken. The pike scene: a moment that will forever be etched in “Walking Dead” history.
• Lydia’s Guilt Trip: “It’s All My Fault!”: Lydia, who’s already struggling with her loyalty to her mother and her growing connection to the survivors, is devastated by the massacre. She blames herself for what happened, believing that if she hadn’t left the Whisperers, her friends would still be alive. Lydia: the girl who’s carrying the weight of the world on her shoulders.
• Siddiq’s Story: The Survivor Who Speaks for the Dead: Siddiq, who was captured by the Whisperers but managed to escape, is found tied to a tree. He recounts the events of the massacre, emphasizing the bravery of those who fought back and the unity that they found in their final moments. His words inspire the survivors and remind them that even in the face of tragedy, they can still find strength in each other. Siddiq: the witness who honors the dead.

Themes and Symbolism:

• Loss: The Price of Peace: The deaths of Tara, Enid, Henry, and the others are a heartbreaking reminder that even in a world that’s trying to rebuild, violence and loss are never far away. The survivors have come so far, but they’re still vulnerable, and their dreams of a better future are constantly being challenged. The Walking Dead: where even the smallest victories can be overshadowed by tragedy.
• Boundaries: The Lines in the Sand: Alpha’s use of the pikes to mark the Whisperers’ territory is a chilling reminder of their power and their ruthlessness. They’re not just a group of survivors; they’re a force of nature, and they’re willing to do whatever it takes to protect their way of life. The Whisperers: they’re not just creepy; they’re also territorial.
• Community: The Strength That Endures: Despite the devastating losses and the looming threat of the Whisperers, the survivors find strength in their community and their shared grief. They come together to mourn their fallen friends, and they vow to continue the fight for a better future. The Walking Dead: where even in the darkest of times, there’s still hope for a brighter tomorrow.

Little Details You Might Have Missed:

• The subtle glances at Michonne and Daryl’s “X” scars are a reminder of their shared traumatic experience in the past and the emotional baggage they still carry. It’s a connection that binds them together and fuels their determination to protect the people they care about. Michonne and Daryl: the warriors who are still haunted by their pasts.
• The charter, which was signed with such hope and optimism earlier in the episode, becomes a tragic symbol of the fragility of peace and the ever-present threat of violence. The charter: a reminder that even the best intentions can be shattered by the harsh realities of the apocalypse.
• Beta’s absence in this episode is ominous. He’s the Whisperers’ second-in-command, and his absence suggests that he’s out there, lurking in the shadows, and planning something sinister. Beta: the silent threat that’s waiting to strike.
• Carol’s reaction to Henry’s death is a callback to her earlier losses, particularly Sophia and Lizzie. She’s a mother who’s lost children before, and her grief is compounded by the guilt and the feeling that she could have done more to protect him. Carol Peletier: the woman who’s haunted by the ghosts of her past.

Stats and Stuff:

• Viewer Ratings: 4.15 million viewers (the Whisperers are still a ratings hit!).
• Critic Reception: 94% rating on Rotten Tomatoes (critics agree – this episode is a masterpiece!).
• Character Death Count: 10 (the pike scene is one of the most shocking moments in “Walking Dead” history).

My Final Verdict (With Extra Pizzazz):

“The Calm Before” is a masterpiece of tension, heartbreak, and storytelling. The juxtaposition of the fair’s joy with the Whisperers’ cruelty creates a haunting and unforgettable episode that will stay with you long after the credits roll. The pike scene is a gut-wrenching moment that redefines the stakes of the conflict and solidifies the Whisperers as one of the most menacing threats in the “Walking Dead” universe. What did you think of the episode? Were you shocked by the pike scene? Let’s discuss in the comments!